exoskeleton vs. intraskeleton for social networking: external services examining links between blogs and other sites (i.e. technorati.com ; seeing what youtube video is most frequently posted) vs. internal suggestions within an online community (i.e. facebook, myspace, youtube; suggesting friends). The exoskeleton format is less friendly to new users.
I've been on livejournal (exoskeleton) since July 2004, but it's only been within the past 4 years or so that I began to explore the community potential of the site.
Social Network Theory suggests that it's not the close friendships but the acquaintanceships that are really helpful in getting cutting-edge news, and I've found this to be absolutely true in my livejournal community experience. I don't have to be close friends with people within the community to read the information they post, and within the community it's certainly easy to make either friends or enemies. Because the communities I've been a part of are all composed of such diverse groups, a variety of new information is generated frequently.
The internet is a distributed network, with every computer designed to link to another computer as opposed to a central hub (more difficult to knock out this way, as evidenced by pieces of livejournal going down last year when ontd got so big), and the social aspect of blogging communities is the same way. The book suggests that more hits lead to increased blog popularity which leads to decreased personal interaction among readers and the blog author, and this is certainly true for my livejournal experiences. Shirky's assessment of social problems on blogs is correct: cliquishness occurs and the idea of a "core group" is definitely established, usually based on 1) how willing a person is to participate in discussion with other members within the blogging community and 2) how much time a person dedicates to the community.
Conversation between blogs is asynchronous; users are not required to be present at the same time; however, in my experience, this is frequently the case. Real-time conversations are common on livejournal, especially within communities such as the ones I frequent where users are predominantly college-age--because we're already on the internet for various purposes, it's simple to respond to a quick comment when the notification pops up in our inbox. Some users thrive on real-time conversation within blog posts and will just sit in a post waiting to jump into a conversation (not as lame as it sounds, I promise).
This chapter also addresses the spread of information via blogs, and this is where our current event discussion from Thursday comes in. Events such as the earthquake in Haiti and last summer's election in Iran were covered thoroughly by the blogosphere (I include twitter in this, particularly for the #iranelection hashtag that was constantly trending last summer), and the latest event that I heard about via blogging is the flooding in Pakistan. I admittedly don't watch a lot of news; I'll read what's linked to me and what @cnnbrk tweets, and occasionally I'll skim the CNN overview email that's sent to my inbox every morning. I had heard nothing about the floods in Pakistan until this post, which was much, much later than the problem initially started. It seems strange to me that I haven't heard much talk of this in real life (as opposed to the earthquakes in Haiti and Chile, which everyone was talking about) and that it's still such a problem for all these people.
I thought this chapter's discussion of facebook as a blog (with facebook serving as the narrator) was kind of interesting but ultimately not the idea behind blogging. The content is not at all self-generated, aside from status updates (which might as well be twitter/microblogging). Wall posts are more like comments or messages. Rettberg's observations about the diversity of her facebook friends (re: the VT shootings) seems more typical with the concept of a blogging community to me--I feel like I've experienced a much more diverse view of the world through the posts and opinions of my friends from other states/countries/backgrounds.
Four characteristics of online social spaces fundamentally different from offline social spaces:
1. Persistence - information is recorded and can be accessed later; I now have horrific archives from my sophomore-senior years in high school that capture memories I wish I could erase. I could delete them, but I also sort of like having them.
2. Searchability - information can be found easily via google and things. This is less relevant in my case because I keep my blog locked (and I have one of the most common last names in the world).
3. Replicability - things can be copied and modified so there's no way to tell them apart from the original. Again less relevant in my case but more relevant to some of my friends who are good at photoshop and making clever macros that they will probably never get credited for as the images spread around the internet.
4. Invisible audiences - no idea who is viewing your profile or reading your blog.
The issue with a variety of different groups of people reading your blog/facebook/twitter feed can be easily solved by keeping tabs on who is reading what. I try to keep my facebook PG-rated after my 11-year old cousin and his parents befriended me, but my blog is locked to just my friends, and I can therefore be more free with my speech. My twitter account is a weird mixture of people I know online, in real life, and from last semester's english 465 class, but it's also locked, so I feel freer to speak there as well.
This chapter wraps up by examining blogging as a narrative: by compiling everything a user posts to the internet, it paints a fairly thorough picture of their life. This is why I can't bring myself to delete my old livejournal posts or to delete my facebook or my twitter (although I did delete my myspace; bad memories). I'm a sucker for nostalgia, and I can spend hours flipping through old pictures or entries. It's fascinating to me the amount of detail I sometimes used in documenting the mundane events of my life and the emotions that went along with them, and I've actually found a lot of advice from my former self in this way.
No comments:
Post a Comment