This chapter explores the idea of citizen journalism, as opposed to traditional mass media journalism. Is blogging journalism? Blogging is frequently opinion as opposed to fact (what traditional journalists aim to report), but the relationship bloggers establish with their readers tends to lead to readers trusting a blogger more than a news source. Most bloggers don't really consider themselves journalists, but by blogging they are publishing and spreading their information and ideas.
The problem here comes into play when a legal definition of journalism is required. Many bloggers acquire press passes to major political events in addition to traditional journalists. When bloggers use anonymous sources, are those sources protected under the same confidentiality laws that journalists' sources are? The example Rettberg gives is a lawsuit between Apple and a blogger--the court decided that the blogger's source was indeed protected.
A complaint levied toward bloggers as an alternative for traditional news sources is that bloggers are definitively biased in their posting of their opinions. Again, this sometimes serves to establish trust: because bloggers clearly state their own personal beliefs/bias, readers begin to see them as a person as opposed to an organization-type news source. Examples are given in this chapter as well where blogging is a valuable insight into various situations where traditional journalism would not suffice. Both blogs from Iraq (one from an Iraqi citizen and one from a soldier) allow readers to experience something that's being reported firsthand through the words of someone else's personal experience. The posts are just describing their everyday lives, but they allow readers to have a personal twist to their perception of the Iraq situation.
The Virginia Tech student's livejournal is another example of this personal twist, but in this case the student was a chance witness, not purposefully blogging in a warzone. He probably didn't expect responses from journalists on his livejournal post; he was just relaying a raw emotional response to the tragedies of that day.
This chapter also delves into the idea of blogs as "gatewatchers," filtering through news to find the most relevant stories to a particular group as soon as it appears (ie, Digg). These blogs link to other sites (frequently mainstream news sites) as opposed to generating their own content (comment sections notwithstanding). Bloggers also frequently work as watchdogs, correcting news releases, sometimes on a very large scale (ie, Rathergate). Rettberg concludes this chapter by suggesting a symbiotic relationship existing currently between blog sites and traditional news media.
No comments:
Post a Comment